Showing posts with label great kata debate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label great kata debate. Show all posts

Sunday, February 17, 2008

American Bo Form

I'm struggling with the new kata. It's great fun to have a bow (like a long staff). My son and I have spent way too many hours doing "creative" kata in the backyard and learning the basics. So far, one broken glass but no windows or eyes. We started with a broom handle and poker queue stick but now have store-bought bows.

I did get a video of Stefanie doing the kata but it's a little too fast to follow and I filmed it with the camera held sideways. I haven't yet figured out how to rotate it. And I'm finding it very hard to transcribe. Anybody got a great video? Here's a slower one that has only the start (and it's also sideway - PLEASE - if you see me holding the camera sideways - give me a Boot to the Head).





Here's the sequence that I've figured out so far.
  1. The Bow is held on right side, vertically. Tip the bow forward, bow, return to start.
  2. Spin over head to hold it out to the right, on one knee, left hand outstretched
  3. Bring it over head while putting 2nd knee down, lowering the bow horizontally in front of you.
  4. Bow to knees, spread knees slightly, drop then raise head
  5. Step up with left knee while bringing bow over head to the right, strike forward, back, spin over head bringing it behind the head from the left side and overhead strike forward finishing on left
  6. Stand by putting on leg up then down, forward back on left, to the right and back,
  7. Turn 90 to the right taking a small adjustment with the right foot to the right, spin bow over head to the right side, forward, back, to the left, back over head, then strike finishing in hard bow with the right leg forward
  8. High dragon (poke up to the guy on horseback) forward, then low dragon (poke the guy on the ground) backwards
  9. Turn the body 180 making only a slight back (left) foot adjustment step to the left. Hit with the bow to the left, back to the right, hit up, hit down, hit to the left, bring it over the head and down while stepping forward with the right foot into a hard bow - aieesa
PS - For you linguists out there. You might have noticed the confusion between the word bow (as in a long staff) and bow as in what we do from the waist to show respect. I am hyper aware of these issues since one of my alternative identities is as Mayor of SpellingCity.com where I obsess over issues like homophones, homonyms, and "Same spelling, different sound, different words" (which I can't seem to find a name for).

Friday, February 01, 2008

kata for soccer & basketball - The Great Debate

I've trained in the martial arts for four years. I've spent alot of time learning and enjoying my kata. I've recently become interested in the greater issues and trends in the martial arts and I've become aware of the "Great Kata Debate". Simply, are kata useful as a training tool to learn to fight or are they only useful for demonstration, sports, training etc?

It occurred to me today that there are no soccer kata. All the soccer players in the world practice soccer in a variety of methods and drills. But, to my knowledge, none of them spend time memorizing and perfecting a stylized set of moves with the ball and body meant as a prelude to playing soccer. When we juggle and kick, we aim for control but never exact repetition.

Basketball too. There are no basketball kata in which you start at the foul line, spin around dribbling with one hand, spin back dribbling with the other, do a fade-away jump shot which comes off the front left of the basket which you catch and then dunk. Followed by a left handed layup etc etc.

My point is this. In these sports, you prepare to play by practicing repetitively but always with a degree of spontenity. You dribble and you shoot (in either sport) with precision but never in the type of repetitive preciseness called for by martial arts kata. Its more like shadow boxing, bag work, or light sparring.

Whats your conclusion?

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Karate across the pond: “karate-do” vs “karate-jutsu”.

I'm driving for 3 hours on Thursday and back on Friday (Orlando for FETC).

I'd like to enjoy the drive so I've been hoping to understand how to download and listen to podcasts. Sadly, my newly repaired ipod still won't get recognized by the computer.

But, in preparing, I looked and round and listened to a podcast (online) from Iain Abernethy, a martial artist from across the pond. Let's start with the obvious. Great accent, hard work for us yanks to follow.

When I was in London (for 5 years before moving to Flordia), I would often turn to my colleagues during a meeting and ask them about an accent (actually, we would usually do this during a tea break or in the loo). My friends could tell me alot about someone based on the accent. eg - Upper crust pretensions, fancy schools, but not to the manor-born. Or, north country, school up there, notice the short sleeves and friendly attitude. Or, Scotsman thru and thru. He's not buying, let's not waste any time.

I was amazed and intrigued by the accent recognition game. I never made much progress in being able to recognize them myself. All this by way of saying that despite his conspicuous accent, I can't place him regionally or otherwise although I'm sure that I should be able to since it sounds very familiar (my only success in recognition was occassionally I could recognize an accent as identical to someone else's which effectively gave me the basics).

Iain's podcast was on “karate-do” vs “karate-jutsu”. He starts with:

The term “karate-do” has become associated with ineffective karate that makes little or no attempt to train in a realistic way....In contrast.... the practitioners of “karate-jutsu” are often viewed as dangerous psychotics who revel in violence and are base individuals unable to appreciate the higher aspects of the martial arts...

He ends by saying that they are two halves of the same coin which I find very diplomatic. Perhaps too diplomatic. I'm curious in more of a "take" as in: ....training to fight without the -do-training in patience and displine, is too dangerous and likely to lead to problems....Schools on the -jutsu side tend to foster....(this is an example, not a viewpoint)

It's definitely worth a listen especially if you like their use of a more interesting vocabulary than is in common-usage Stateside. Also, the discussion somewhat parallels the Great Kata debate. Do we use the -do and -jutsu terms in this country?

Undergoing MyBlogLog Verification